First off, I would like to thank my friend Bart Cameron for sharing those photos with this group. That is very much appreciated.
For most of you who have inhabited this board for any length of time, you may have concluded that I can be brutally honest in some of my replies. This..............will be no exception. :sidelaugh:
Dan Haas is to be congratulated for his efforts to create an annual gathering of people that own Colt, Case and Ingersoll tractors. Exhibited at this show, once again, were some machines that you will likely not come across elsewhere. In particular, I am referring to the Experimental Ingersoll 4525K prototype and the Ingersoll 448 Utility Transport.
When it comes to near perfect workmanship, the 3427 Articulated built by Dan Haas along with his self-powered trailer are on a parallel with the Orchard tractor depicted and the self-detaching loader plus box blade built by Steve Halfpap ( a member of this forum) as well as the cab built by Grummy who is a Keystone Member of this forum. It pleases me to see two Colts making it to the show this time as I am unaware of even a single Colt making an appearance in 2010. With luck, more will turn up at next year's event.
The restoration work on the Colt Deluxe looks very good. I hope that the same thing happens to the Super H. The trencher appears to be the one owned by Herm Krueger and for the record, those were mounted on the 190 models, not the 180. The CK55 crawler based on a 155 tractor is a nice piece but I think that the exhaust system detracts from overall image. Based upon the photos taken by Bart, the predominant colour scheme at the show seems to be Desert Sunset and one of the Reds. To me, this is how it should be. Most of the Sunset tractors have earned their permanent retirement and this is how they should be treated from here-on in.
And now we get to the brutal part...........
There is this word in the English language known as "restoration" and like many words we use, people can interpret them differently. To me, the word restoration means that you return an item to the way it was when it was originally manufactured. It's a black or white issue for me. So when I see some of the tractors that came to this show, I have to wonder if I have been relying on the wrong definition of the word restore. The owner of the 195 did a fantastic job restoring the Haban sickle bar mower but how can someone be so meticulous on an attachment and then fail to demount your tires when painting the rims? I mean.....c'mon... overspray on your tires is a pretty simple thing to avoid.
If you go to purchase an engagement ring, then it will likely have at least one diamond in it. Anyone who has gone through that agonizing ritual knows that diamonds are judged (graded) by the size and number of flaws they contain and that is one of the things that affects value. You pay a higher price for a diamond that contains no flaws and when I look at restoration work carried out by others, I look the end result the same way. To my way of thinking, it is not all that hard to figure out how the factory put a tractor together and then duplicate it. You are not required to design or engineer anything. Essentially you are nothing more than a copycat. Someone once said "It's all in the small details" and I certainly ascribe to that notion.
There are things that you just should not do such as
- painting your tractor the WRONG colour
- painting certain parts the WRONG colour
- installing a seat that is totally incorrect
- painting over nuts and bolts that should be bright zinc finish
- installing nightmarish exhaust systems designed by the Mario Brothers
- putting exhaust stacks on a tractor that is supposed to be a true restoration
- improper application of decals
- using decals that are not correct
- failing to remove all the bends and dents from the sheet metal
- failing to properly prepare the metal so that rust pock-marking is eliminated
- showing up with trivial items such as knobs or steering wheel caps missing
- using clear seal beam lamps instead of the correct OEM style
- failing to properly remove the rust from perforated grille material
- OVERSPRAY...... anywhere
- failure to have key components re-plated
Am I too tough?
I don't think so but you are free to express you thoughts on this issue. As most of you know, I view this forum as a place of learning. If I don't come out and say that I think this or that are wrong, then I don't think that I'm doing my job. I also don't think that I'm doing the hobby or this membership any good either because we should all aspire to produce true restorations that cannot be faulted in any way. I don't know who the owners of those tractors are by name. Some of them may well be members of this site. If they are.......and they are unhappy with me holding up the mirror, then perhaps they need to examine the quality of their own workmanship in the true light of day. When you voluntarily put yourself on stage, then you can expect to be judged by those who are viewing you. That's the way of the world.
-